Winter Is Coming: The Best Use of Solar PV Under Net Billing in Pakistan
An economist’s guide to moving winter gas load onto surplus midday solar, and to knowing when to keep your gas.
اردو میں پڑھیں ←Every autumn, Pakistani households start thinking about gas: the geyser, the heater, the winter bill. Rooftop solar owners face a different question. Under net billing, the midday surplus from their panels sells to the grid for only about Rs 10 to 11 per unit. Is there a better home for those units? As an economist, my answer is: sometimes yes, often no, and the difference comes down to one simple comparison that most people have never been shown.
The principle is this. A unit of solar electricity has no fixed value. Its value is the best alternative it replaces. A surplus unit can be exported, it can cancel a unit you would otherwise import from the grid, or it can replace gas or LPG that you would otherwise burn. Each destination pays a different amount, and the smart move is to send every unit to the highest paying one.
This article gives you the arithmetic, states every assumption openly, and ends with a decision rule you can apply to your own bills. It also says plainly when the right answer is to keep your gas, because for many households that is exactly what the numbers show.
1. Two Kinds of Solar Owners, Two Different Answers
New prosumers under net billing
Under the NEPRA (Prosumer) Regulations 2026, applications made after 9 February 2026 fall under net billing. Exported surplus is bought at roughly Rs 10 to 11 per unit, while imports from the DISCO are billed separately at Rs 37 to 55 per unit before taxes, depending on slab. Agreements run for five years. For this group, the economics below apply directly.
Existing net metering holders
Consumers who held valid net metering agreements before 9 February 2026 are in a different position. After public backlash, the Prime Minister directed a review, and NEPRA issued a draft amendment intended to protect existing licence holders under their original terms until expiry. Under those terms, an exported unit offsets an imported unit one for one, which is worth roughly the full import price. For this group, the advice is largely to keep exporting and enjoy the benefit until the agreement expires. I explain the numbers in Section 6.
2. What a Unit of Gas Actually Costs
Gas bills are confusing, so let me strip them to what matters. Piped gas is priced per MMBTU on a progressive slab system, and your status as protected or non-protected is determined by your winter average, the four months from November to February. LPG is priced per kilogram. To compare any of these with electricity, we convert everything to a common unit: the energy in a kilowatt hour. One MMBTU equals about 293 kWh of fuel energy, and one kilogram of LPG holds roughly 12.8 kWh.
| Energy source | Price | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Piped gas, protected | Rs 200 to 350 per MMBTU, fixed charge Rs 600 | Winter average at or below 0.9 hm3 |
| Piped gas, non-protected | Progressive slabs from about Rs 500 up to Rs 4,200 per MMBTU; fixed charge Rs 1,500 or Rs 3,000 | OGRA rates effective 1 July 2025 |
| LPG | Rs 279.34 per kg, or Rs 3,296.23 per 11.8 kg cylinder | OGRA maximum price, effective 1 October 2026 |
| Grid electricity, import | Rs 37 to 55 per unit before taxes | Depends on slab |
| Solar export, new prosumers | About Rs 10 to 11 per unit | NEPRA Prosumer Regulations 2026 |
One number deserves emphasis. At Rs 279.34 per kg, LPG costs the same as piped gas priced at roughly Rs 6,400 per MMBTU. That is higher than any domestic slab. Households that depend on LPG cylinders are paying the most expensive winter energy in the country.
3. What One Surplus Solar Unit Is Worth
Here is the heart of the analysis. When one kilowatt hour of surplus solar electricity replaces gas, it does not replace one kilowatt hour of gas. Electric appliances waste less. An induction hob puts most of its energy into the pot, a gas burner loses a lot to the room. A heat pump moves heat rather than making it, so one unit of electricity delivers roughly three units of heat. The value of a solar unit therefore depends on how much gas it displaces.
The formula is simple: value of one solar unit = (useful heat delivered per unit of electricity ÷ efficiency of the gas appliance) × price of one kWh of gas energy.
| One surplus solar unit used for | Protected gas (Rs 200 to 350) | Gas at Rs 1,250 | Gas at Rs 1,450 | Gas at Rs 4,200 | LPG at Rs 279/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Export under net billing | Rs 11 | Rs 11 | Rs 11 | Rs 11 | Rs 11 |
| Induction cooking | Rs 1 to 2 | Rs 7.3 | Rs 8.4 | Rs 24.4 | Rs 37.2 |
| Inverter AC heating | Rs 2 to 4 | Rs 14.2 | Rs 16.5 | Rs 47.8 | Rs 72.9 |
| Heat pump hot water | Rs 3 to 6 | Rs 21.3 | Rs 24.7 | Rs 71.7 | Rs 109 |
Read the table against the first row. Any cell worth more than Rs 11 (shaded) beats exporting, and shifting that load onto your midday surplus is financially rational. Three patterns stand out:
- Protected gas is unbeatable. At Rs 200 to 350 per MMBTU, no electric option comes close to Rs 11. If you are protected, keep your gas.
- Heat pumps win almost everywhere else. Hot water and room heating clear the Rs 11 bar even at the first non-protected slabs.
- Induction cooking only wins against expensive fuel. At the first non-protected slabs, gas is still slightly cheaper than solar surplus for cooking. At top slabs and with LPG, induction wins clearly.
4. Where to Start: Hot Water First, Then Heating, Then Cooking
Hot water: the cheapest battery you can buy
Hot water is the best first move, and it comes with a bonus. An insulated tank is a thermal battery. You heat the water at noon, when solar is abundant, and use it at six the next morning. No lithium cell required.
The heat needed is about 4.65 kWh. What it costs to deliver that heat:
Gas geyser (60 percent efficient) at Rs 1,250 per MMBTU: about Rs 33. At Rs 1,450: about Rs 38. At Rs 4,200: about Rs 111.
LPG geyser at Rs 279 per kg: about Rs 169.
Heat pump on surplus solar (about 1.55 kWh of electricity, valued at the Rs 11 export price): about Rs 17.
Plain electric storage geyser on surplus solar (about 5.2 kWh of electricity): about Rs 57.
Notice the last two lines. A plain resistive geyser loses to non-protected gas at the lower slabs, because it makes one unit of heat per unit of electricity. A heat pump wins comfortably. The technology matters as much as the tariff.
Room heating: pre-heat at midday
An inverter air conditioner in heating mode works on the same heat pump principle. Run it through the sunny hours to warm the rooms and the building fabric, and you carry some of that warmth into the evening. Be realistic about the limits. Solar stops at sunset, and the coldest hours are at night, so you will still need another source for late evening and early morning unless you have storage.
Cooking: useful, but the smallest prize
Cooking is the least valuable shift for piped gas households, as the table shows. It still makes sense for LPG users, for households on top gas slabs, and for anyone who values speed, safety, and a cleaner kitchen. If you cook with induction, aim the biggest cooking job of the day, usually lunch, at the midday solar window, and use batch cooking and insulated pots to carry the benefit further.
5. The Biggest Lever May Be Your Gas Category
Here is the idea that most households miss. Gas status is decided by your average consumption over the four winter months, November to February. Hot water and space heating are the largest winter gas loads. If moving them onto solar electricity brings your winter average under the protected threshold of 0.9 hm3, your remaining gas, mostly cooking, is billed at Rs 200 to 350 per MMBTU with a Rs 600 fixed charge instead of non-protected rates and a Rs 1,500 or Rs 3,000 fixed charge.
Suppose your remaining cooking gas is 2 MMBTU a month.
As non-protected at Rs 1,250: Rs 2,500 plus Rs 1,500 fixed charge, about Rs 4,000.
As protected at Rs 250: Rs 500 plus Rs 600 fixed charge, about Rs 1,100.
That is a difference of roughly Rs 2,900 a month before taxes, simply from where your gas is categorised.
6. If You Are an Existing Net Metering Holder: Keep the Benefit
For consumers whose agreements still run on the original terms, an exported unit is credited one for one against imports. That makes each exported unit worth roughly the price of the unit it cancels. Taking Rs 45 as an illustrative mid-point of the Rs 37 to 55 range, look again at the chart. The green dashed line sits at Rs 45, and almost every bar falls below it.
- Piped gas households: keep exporting. Using a Rs 45 unit to cook or heat water is a poor trade against gas at any slab up to Rs 1,450.
- Top slab gas and LPG households: a heat pump for hot water or heating can still clear Rs 45, particularly with LPG, where it is worth Rs 73 to 109 per unit.
- Induction cooking: does not clear Rs 45 even against LPG. Keep the one for one credit working for you.
Plan ahead for expiry. When an agreement ends, renewals fall under net billing, and the logic of Sections 3 to 5 takes over. A heat pump water heater or induction hob bought now will serve you well in either world.
7. Practical Guardrails
- Winter solar output is lower. Shorter days, a low sun angle, and fog and smog across northern Punjab all reduce generation. Use last winter’s monitoring data to see how much real surplus you have before buying anything.
- Shift surplus, not imports. The arithmetic only works when the unit would otherwise be exported. Never import grid power at Rs 37 to 55 to run something that gas does for less.
- Check your electrical capacity. A 2 kW induction hob plus a geyser can exceed what an old circuit, socket, or sanctioned load can carry. Use dedicated, correctly rated circuits, and avoid daisy chained extension boards.
- It helps the grid too. Midday electrification absorbs power that would otherwise flow backward onto the LT feeder, easing the voltage rise problem that limits how much solar a network can host.
8. A Checklist Before November
- Confirm which agreement you are on: net metering or net billing.
- Find your gas category and the slab rates on your latest bill.
- Check last winter’s solar monitoring data for midday surplus.
- Identify your largest winter gas loads: hot water, heating, or cooking.
- Price a heat pump water heater and an insulated tank first.
- Have an electrician confirm your circuit and sanctioned load capacity.
Key Takeaways
- A solar unit is worth what it replaces. Under net billing, the bar to beat is the export price of about Rs 11.
- Keep protected gas. At Rs 200 to 350 per MMBTU, no electric option competes.
- Heat pumps are the winning technology. Hot water and heating clear the bar at most non-protected slabs and decisively against LPG.
- Cooking is the smallest prize. Induction wins mainly against LPG and top gas slabs.
- Existing net metering holders should mostly keep exporting, and plan for the day their agreement expires.
- Moving winter heating loads may change your gas category, which can be the largest saving of all, but it needs to start before November.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources Referenced
- Dawn, “Nepra pulls the plug on net-metering” dawn.com/news/1972203
- Business Recorder, “Nepra notifies Prosumer Regulations” brecorder.com
- Profit by Pakistan Today, “After PM’s orders, NEPRA grants 30-day protection to existing net-metering consumers” profit.pakistantoday.com.pk
- OGRA domestic gas tariff effective 1 July 2025, as reported by Profit profit.pakistantoday.com.pk and summarised at toolsfluent.com
- Mettis Global, “OGRA sets LPG maximum consumer price at Rs279.34 per kg from October 1” mettisglobal.news
